Barsys
Smoky Cinnamon Margarita
About
The Smoky Cinnamon Margarita is what happens when classic citrus meets cozy spice and decides to throw a party. This version leans on Teremana Reposado, fresh orange and lime juice, and agave for a naturally bright, smooth base. Then comes the fun part: a toasted cinnamon stick that adds warm smoke, aroma, and just enough intrigue to make the whole drink feel elevated.
It’s bold without being heavy, warm without being sweet, and refreshing enough to sip year-round. Think of it as the margarita’s suave cousin - familiar, but a lot more interesting.
Shaken or Stirred? Shaken. Toast the cinnamon, drop it in, and shake until the shaker chills your soul.
What You'll Need
Single Serve
- 2 oz Teremana Reposado Tequila
- 1 oz Fresh Orange Juice
- 1 oz Fresh Lime Juice
- 0.5 oz Light Agave Syrup
- 1 toasted cinnamon stick (3")
- Orange slices & salt for serving
Pro Tip: Toast the cinnamon stick until fragrant - not charred. Light smoke = flavor. Flames = regret.
How to Make It
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Skill Level: Easy with flair
- Combine tequila, orange juice, lime juice, and agave syrup in a shaker.
- Toast a cinnamon stick using a culinary torch, gas flame, or lighter until aromatic.
- Drop the toasted cinnamon stick into the shaker.
- Shake vigorously until cold (about 30 seconds).
- Strain into an ice-filled, salt-rimmed glass.
- Garnish with a fresh cinnamon stick and an orange slice.
Using Barsys?
Barsys 360 Cocktail Maker can handle your tequila, lime, orange, and agave perfectly. Let the machine pour the precise ratios - then finish the drink manually with toasted cinnamon for that smoky, handcrafted finish. The best of both worlds: consistency + drama.
For the full recipe, download the Barsys App.
Tasting Notes
The Barsys Edge
The Smoky Cinnamon Margarita depends on precision - too much citrus dulls the warmth, too much agave overshadows the spice, and uneven tequila pours throw the whole balance off. Barsys nails these measurements every single time, giving you a perfectly structured base so the toasted cinnamon aroma shines through. Instead of worrying about ratios, you get to focus on the part that makes this cocktail special: building the smoke, the spice, and the final dramatic presentation.
Sip Setting
Perfect for chilly evenings, fireside hangs, rooftop sunsets, or anytime you want your margarita with a little extra personality. It’s warm, aromatic, and guaranteed to get people asking, “Wait what’s in this?”
Garnish Game
Salt rim, toasted cinnamon stick, and a bright slice of orange. If you’re feeling extra, torch the cinnamon stick again right before serving for a moment of pure cocktail theater.
You may also like
FAQs
Can I make this without toasting the cinnamon?
You can, but the toasted aroma is the whole point. Don’t skip it.
Can I batch this?
Yes - toast multiple cinnamon sticks and let them steep in the mix before chilling.
Can I use Blanco instead of Reposado?
Sure, but you’ll lose the warm, caramelized depth that works so well with cinnamon.
Can I use bottled orange juice?
Fresh tastes brighter and cleaner, but bottled works if you’re in a pinch.
How can I adjust the sweetness?
Add more or less agave depending on your citrus intensity.